Updated September 17, 2026 · 6 min read · Figures labeled as published 2026 ranges, not Silcott quotes
Cost up front
Architectural shingles are the lower first cost by a wide margin. Standing seam metal on a house commonly runs two to three times the shingle price for the same roof in published 2026 Central Ohio ranges. Ribbed exposed-fastener metal on a barn or shop costs less than standing seam and is the standard for agricultural buildings.
Weather in our part of Ohio
Wind across open Pickaway and Fayette County farmland is the main enemy of an aging shingle roof: tabs lift, seals break, and the next storm finishes the job. Properly fastened metal panels hold up better to sustained wind. Hail dents metal and bruises shingles; either can be damaged, and the damage looks different. Snow slides off metal, which is a plus for the roof and something to plan for above doors and walkways. Tree debris and moss in the Hocking Hills side of our area favor metal, which sheds both.
Lifespan expectations
Architectural shingles are generally expected to serve two to three decades depending on exposure and ventilation. Metal roofs are generally expected to last considerably longer. We do not promise a number of years for either; the manufacturer's written warranty for the specific product is the document that counts, and we give it to you with the quote.
Noise, heat, and looks
Over solid decking with underlayment, a metal roof on a house sounds about like a shingle roof in the rain. On an open-framed barn, it is loud. Light-colored metal reflects summer heat. On appearance, standing seam suits farmhouses, modern designs, and cabins; shingles suit most subdivision homes and most HOA color rules.
Insurance and resale
Some insurers offer premium discounts for certain impact-resistant roofing products. Ask your agent which products qualify before you choose; we do not promise a discount. On resale, a newer roof of either type helps. Metal can be a selling point on rural and higher-end properties; on a typical subdivision home, buyers mostly want to know the roof is not due.
Our honest recommendation
Staying ten years or less in a subdivision house: architectural shingles. Farmhouse, cabin, wooded lot, or a roof you never want to replace again: standing seam. Barn, shop, or equipment shed: ribbed metal. Not sure: book the free inspection and we will tell you which one fits your building.