Roof replacement
Roof Replacement in Circleville and Pickaway County
A roof replacement from Silcott Legacy Roofing and Exteriors means a full tear-off, decking repair where it is needed, new underlayment and flashing, and a new architectural shingle or metal roof installed to the manufacturer's specifications. We are based in Circleville and replace roofs across Pickaway County and the surrounding counties.
What we handle
Roof Replacement: what the scope can include
- Complete tear-off, never a layover on top of old shingles
- Decking inspection and replacement of soft or rotted boards
- Ice and water shield at eaves, valleys, and penetrations
- Synthetic underlayment, new drip edge, new step and counter flashing
- Architectural shingles or standing seam metal
- Ridge vent and intake ventilation sized to the attic
- Cleanup with a magnetic nail sweep of the yard and driveway
How a visit works
- 1
Call or request a callback
Tell us what you are seeing. A leak, a storm, an aging roof, or a project you are planning. We set a time that works for you.
- 2
Inspection with photos
Derek walks the roof and the exterior, photographs what he finds, and shows you the pictures. You see the same thing we see.
- 3
Written scope, then the work
You get a written scope of exactly what we recommend and why. Nothing starts until you have it in hand and say go.

Signs a roof is due
Shingles that are cupping, cracking, or losing their granules into the gutters. Bald spots after a wind storm. Flashing that has been tarred over more than once. Stains on the ceiling that come back after every repair. A roof from the 1990s or early 2000s on a subdivision home in Grove City, Canal Winchester, or Ashville is often at that point now.
None of those alone means replace. Together they usually do. The inspection settles it.
Why we tear off instead of laying over
Ohio code allows a second layer of shingles in some cases. We do not do it. A layover hides rotted decking, traps heat that shortens the life of the new shingles, and makes the next replacement cost more. Tearing off lets us see and fix the deck, run ice and water shield where Ohio winters demand it, and start the new roof on a clean surface.
How long a replacement takes
Most single-family roofs in our area are torn off and reroofed in one to two working days once materials are on site, weather permitting. Larger or steeper roofs and roofs with extensive decking repair take longer. You get the plan and the schedule in writing before we start, and we protect landscaping, siding, and the driveway while we work.
What it costs
Every roof is quoted from the actual measurements, pitch, layers, decking condition, and the material you choose. We do not publish prices because two houses on the same street can be very different jobs. Our roof replacement cost guide explains what drives the number in Central Ohio so you can read any quote, including ours, with confidence.
Straight answers
Roof Replacement questions
Will you replace only the damaged side of the roof?
Sometimes, if the rest of the roof is sound and the shingles can be matched. The inspection tells us whether a partial replacement makes sense or just delays the full one.
Do you pull permits?
Where the township, city, or county requires a permit for a roof replacement, we handle it and schedule any required inspection. The written scope notes whether one applies to your address.
What about the gutters during a replacement?
We protect them during tear-off. If they are at the end of their life, replacing gutters at the same time as the roof is usually the cheapest time to do it, and we can quote both.
Can you match my neighbor's roof or my HOA color?
Architectural shingles come in a wide range of colors. Bring the HOA sheet or a photo and we will show you the options that meet it.
Roof Replacement near you
Not on the list? See every town we serve or call (937) 386-4301.
Next step
Talk to the person who will be on your roof.
Call (937) 386-4301 or leave your number. Derek inspects, photographs, and puts the scope in writing before anything starts.
